B5.3 - Ullrich WTP Conversion Composite Evalution Matrix CLMP280

Water and Wastewater Commission – Jan. 8, 2020

B5.3 - Ullrich WTP Conversion Composite Evalution Matrix CLMP280 — original pdf

Backup

Thumbnail of the first page of the PDF — Page 1 of None page

Capital Contracting OfficeEvaluation of Consultant QualificationsCOMPOSITEReceived:EVALUATION MATRIXProject:Ullrich Water Treatment Plant ConversionProject Manager: Item 1Item 2Item 3aItem 3bItem 5Item 6Item 7Item 8[Yes or No][Yes or No][10]20][15][15][10][10][100][15][115]FirmMBE/WBETurned inTeam'sTeam'sPrimeMajor ScopesTeam'sCOATOTALINTERVIEWTOTALRANK(or Joint Venture)Procurementall RequiredStructureApproachFirm'sof WorkExperienceExperiencePOINTSPOINTSPOINTS ProgramDocumentsComparableComparablewithwithWITHProjectProjectAustinPrimeINTERVIEWSPMgrPProfPprinc.ExperienceExperienceIssues[10][6][4]CDM SmithYY8.7016.708.365.312.9611.4813.609.318.8185.2313.999.131CarolloYY8.1014.858.365.013.3112.5513.608.909.0783.7510.6594.42Black & VeatchYY7.3513.605.365.162.4613.0512.257.468.3375.02075.023ArcadisYY6.0513.708.564.462.0611.4011.458.688.3374.69074.694Project Professionaland Project PrincipalExperienceSeptember 11, 2019Nicholas SybilleProject Manager[20]Item 4REVISED 06/01/12Stand Alone Evaluation Matrix