10.2 - 1107 W 9th St - denied H zoning — original pdf

Backup

ZONING CHANGE REVIEW SHEET CASE NUMBER: C14W2010-0022 HLC DATE: PC DATE: June 28. 2010 July26, 2010 December 13, 2010 February 22, 2011 APPLICANTS: Albert Percival, III and Kevin “Chuck” Hughes, owners HISTORIC NAME: Bones-Stokes House WATERSHED: Shoal Creek ADDRESS OF PROPOSED ZONING CHANGE: 1107 w qth Street ZONING FROM: SF3NP to SF3H-NP SUMMARY STAFF RECOMMENI)ATION: Staff cannot recommend the proposed zoning change from family residence — neighborhood plan (SF-3-NP) combining district to family residence — historic landmark — neighborhood plan (SF3-H-NP) combining district zoning because of recent significant modifications to the front of the house. The house is in the proposed Castle Hill Local Historic District. QUALIFICATIONS FOR LANDMARK DESIGNATION: Staff cannot recommend this house for designation as a historic landmark because the architectural character of the house changed substantially in the last year. The house had a projecting canted bay on the right side of the façade, which staff believes was original to the house in form, despite depictions on historical Sanhorn Fire Insurance Company maps. The canted bay was pushed forward several feet in a 1962 remodeling of the house, but still retained its essential form, if not location. In 2010, the owners replaced the canted bay with a boxed picture window, which, while sensitively designed, has compromised the historic appearance of the house to the extent that staff cannot recommend the house for individual designation as it no longer retains sufficient integrity of materials and design to convey’ its historic appearance. HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION ACTION: June 28, 2010: Postponed the case to July 26, 2010 at staffs request so that the applicants could meet with the Certificate of Appropriateness Committee for discussion of the new window on the July 26, 2010: Recommended denial of the proposed zoning façade of the house. change from SF3NP to SF3HNP due to the recent installation of the front window which has compromised the historic appearance of the house. Vote: 6-0 (Kleon absent). NOTE: The applicants were not present at the July 26, 2010 hearing and request a re-hearing of their application. December 13, 2010: The Commission’s action on July 26, 2010 to recommend denial of the proposed zoning change was not rescinded. The motion to rescind failed on a vote of 2-4 (Limbacher, Hansen. Kleon and Meyers opposed; Rosato absent). PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION: Recommended denial of the proposed zoning change from SF-3-NP to SF-3-H-NP due to the modifications to the front façade of the house. Vote: 8-0 (Reddy off-dais). DEPARTMENT COMMENTS: The house is listed as a Priority 2 for research in the Comprehensive Cultural Resources Survey (1984). CITY COUNCIL DATE: March 10. 2011 ACTION: ORDINANCE REAIUNGS: 1ST 2ND 3RD ORDINANCE NUMBER: CASE MANAGER: Steve Sadowsky PHONW 974-6454 NEIGHBORHOOD ORGANIZATION: Old West Austin Neighborhood Association BASIS FOR RECOMMENIJATION: Architectur& One-and-a-half stmy wing-and-gable plan hipped-roof frame transitional cottage with hipped dormers and a partial-width inset wraparound porch on square wood posts with minimal plain brackets. Fenestration consists of 1:1 wood units in single and paired units. The house has a Ca. 2010 boxed multi-light picture window on the right side of the facade, which replaced a canted bay with three 1:1 wood windows. Historical Associations: This ca. 1909 house sits on property which was originally part of the Raymond Estate. which occupied a large part of what is now the XVest Line National Register Historic District. G.M. Brass, who owned the house across the street from this house, purchased this property from the Raymond heirs in 1901 and sold it to A.W. and Ida Brill in 1906. Brill owned the lot to the west as well, and built his house there in 1909, the same year he sold this property to the first owners and occupants of this house, Omer D. and Pearl Bones. Bones executed a contract with the Calcasieu Lumber Company for the construction of this house in July, 1909. Omer Bones was born in Missouri in 1872 and moved to Austin around 1881. He and his wife Pearl appear in the 1900 U.S. Census in Austin as living at 96 Trinity Street in the home of her mother, Mary Leonard. Bones was listed as working in the grocery business. He and Pearl were living at 401 E. 1t Street when they purchased this property in 1909. The 1910 U.S. Census shows them at this house. He and Pearl had two young boys, Shirley, age 5, and Vinson, age 3. Bones was hsted as working for a packing company. City directories show that Bones was the city salesman for Armour and Company, a beef packing house at 4th and Brazos at the time he purchased this property. but had gone to work for Swift and Company, another meat packing plant, by 1912. He and Pearl sold this house in 1913 to Julia Stokes, and moved to 3904 Avenue D. Bones operated a grocery store at 2520-22 Guadalupe Street with Walter H. Morris in the mid- 1910s, then became the storekeeper and accountant at the Austin State School, a position he held for 2-5 years. After Pearl Bones died in 1924, he married his second wife. Louise, who was a seamstress at the Austin State School. In 1930, he and Louise were living on the campus of the school. He died in 1941 at the age of 69. Among his honorary pallbearers were JR. Reed, proprietor of the music store on Congress Avenue, Theo Davis. the son of Nelson Davis, a large wholesale grocery business, and F.W. Sternenberg. the proprietor of a large lumberyard. Omer Bones sold the house in 1913 to Julia Stokes, who moved here with her son Edward and daughter Agnes from a house near Rosewood and Chestnut in East Austin. The family had originally lived in Govalle. where Julia’s husband John had been a rubber stamp maker before he passed away in 1908. Edward Stokes was a traveling salesman for a wholesale grocery company, and went to work for \VeIls Fargo in 1918. He was the cashier for Railway Express until his retirement in the late 1950s. He passed away in 1961. His first wife, Ruby, passed away in June, 1945; his second wife, Jewel, lived here until her death at the age of 101 in 1996. PARCEL NO.: 01090104110000 LEGAL DESCRIPTION: Lot 8, Block A, Outlot 2, Division Z, Raymond Subdivision. ESTIMATED ANNUAL TAX ABATEMENT: $ 8,282 (owner-occupied); city portion: $2,000 (capped). APPRAISED VALUE: $762592 PRESENT USE: Residence CONDITION: Excellent PRESENT OWNERS: Albert Percival, III and Kevin Hughes 1107 W. 9th Street Austin, Texas 78703 DATE BUILT: ca. 1909 ALTERATIONS/ADDITIONS: The house was enlarged toward the rear and a back porch added between 1922 and 1935; the front canted bay of the house, if not original, was also added during that time- The front canted bay of the house was extended in the same configuration in 1962; that bay was transformed into a rectangular space with a boxed multi-light picture window in 2010. The kitchen has also been enlarged and has new windows on the back of the house. ORIGINAL OWNER(S): Omer D. and Pearl Bones (1909) OTHER HISTORICAL DESIGNATIONS: Contributing to the West Line National Register Historic District and located in the potential Castle Hill Local Historic District. ___ LOCATION MAP cN:./ / /Iy / JcsuJt I audcos, 0-W 2:7 • { / i’ ‘7Q’j;! %-4 _ 7 / ,LSj- 7+/i r-...-.’ Q ?S’7 tt4*1a7-4J’ :74& 1 /?; ,;‘;::ZZ 1—-.;—. .‘... .zf..,; I AJ/L ‘_%%. 1’ ,7 / / P )t / -...J(,/__/ / , F4 J L- ..• / /iih47S> < caau vco. f N i/ /L:.. • • • SLBJEDTTRCT PENDINGCSE — — — ZON N3 BDIJKDkRY HISTORIC ZONING ZjNIN’D CASE# C14I-I-2010-0022 LCCATION IIO7 9TH ST GRID H23 MANA ER- S SAUO\SKY / 7. // /li7 ‘ / / % - 7 - .‘ . - flsrnap,as bE-er couca I3•.flgEm€e)pflEe SeeD b o’An’ r. reaet P ,wDep r±eecpu’pcs.c’ecra rre’a’n e No rrIy —- h-mclcry ia—agem n C ona’’e 3oey re cm’!-.’- carom pec ft azcrcy or ompete,ess rA Current view of the Bones-Stokes House Detail of the new window on the front of the house. 1107W gth Street Ca. 1909 It -/ - - NOTE: This Photograph was taken in 2009. OCCUPANCY HISTORY 1107 W. 9 Street City Directory Research, Austin History Center By City Historic Preservation Office Aprfl, 2009 1990 1984 1918 1972 Jewel T. Stokes, owner Retired Jewel T. Stokes, owner Retired Jewel T. Stokes, Owner Widow, Edward W. Stokes Retired Jewel T. Stokes, owner Widow, Edward W. Stokes Retired 1967 1962 1957 1953 1949 1947 Jewel T. Stokes, owner Widow, Edward W. Stokes Retired Jewel T. Stokes, owner Widow, Edward W. Stokes No occupation listed Jewel T. Stokes, owner Book-keeper, Woolworth’s, 600 Congress Avenue Edward W. and Jewell T. Stokes, owners Cashier, Railway Express (Rodney C. Hardin, general agent); Depot, 111 E. 9th Street, office, 123W. 3rd Street. Edward W. Stokes, owner (no wife listed) Cashier, Railway Express (Ray L. Linihan, general agent); Depot, 111 E. gth Street, office, 123W. 3 Street. Edward W. Stokes, owner (no wife listed) Cashier, Railway Express (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent); Depot, 111 E. 9b Street, office, 123W. 3rd Street. 1944-45 Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes, owners Cashier, Railway Express (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent); Depot 111 E. 9th Street, office, 123W. 3rd Street. 1942 1940 1937 1935 Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes, owners Cashier, Railway Express (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent); Depot 111 E. gIb Street, office, 123W. 3rd Street. Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes, owners Cashier, Railway Express (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent); Depot 111 E. 9th Street, office, 123 W. 3rd Street. Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes, owners Cashier, Railway Express (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent); Depot 111 F. 9’ Street, office, 123 W. 3 Street. Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes, owners Cashier, Railway Express (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent); Depot 300 Colorado Street, office, 123 W. 3’° Street. 1932-33 Julia Stokes, owner Widow, John F. Stokes No occupation listed Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes Cashier, Railway Express Agency (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent), 300 Colorado Street. 1930-31 Julia Stokes, owner Widow, John F. Stokes No occupation listed 1929 1927 1924 Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes Cashier, Railway Express Agency (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent), 300 Colorado Street. Julia Stokes, owner Widow, John F. Stokes No occupation listed Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes Cashier, American Railway Express Company (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent), 123W. 6th Street. Julia Stokes, owner Widow, John F. Stokes No occupation listed Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes Cashier, American Railway Express Company (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent), 123W. 6th Street. Julia Stokes, owner Widow, John F. Stokes No occupation listed Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes Cashier, American Railway Express Company (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent), 123W. 6tn Street. Also listed is Agnes Stokes, a seamstress at E.M. Scarbrough & Sons. 1922 Julia Stokes, owner Widow, John F. Stokes No occupation listed Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes Cashier, American Railway Express Company (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent), 123W. 6th Street. Also listed is Agnes Stokes, an alterations assistant at E.M. Scarbrough & Sons. 1920 Julia Stokes, owner Widow, John F. Stokes No occupation listed Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes Cashier, American Railway Express Agency (Edgar L. Bodelle, general agent), 123W. 6th Street. Also listed is Agnes Stokes, a seamstress at E.M. Scarbrough & Sons. 1918 Julia Stokes, owner Widow, John F. Stokes No occupation listed Edward W. and Ruby B. Stokes Money clerk, Wells Fargo & Company Express (J.C. Hill, agent), 121 W. 6th Street. Also listed is Agnes Stokes, a seamstress at EM. Scarbrough & Sons. 1916 Edward W. Stokes Salesman Julia Stokes No occupation listed Agnes Stokes Seamstress, E.M. Scarbrough & Sons. 1914 Edward W. Stokes Salesman Julia Stokes No occupation listed Agnes Stokes Seamstress, E.M. Scarbrough & Sons. 1912-13 OmerD. Bones City salesman, Swift & Company, meats, 311 Congress Avenue NOTE: In the 1914 city directory, Omer D. Bones is listed as a proprietor (with Walter H. Morris) of Morris Brothers, groceries, 2520-22 Guadalupe Street. Omer Bones had moved to a house at 3904 Avenue D. NOTE: The 1912-13 city directory shows Edward W. Stokes as a traveling salesman for W.B. Walker & Sons, a wholesale grocery and coffee roasting business located at 301-11 W. 4tb Street. He, Agnes, and Julia are listed as living 2 blocks south of Rosewood Avenue and 3 blocks east of Chestnut Avenue in East Austin. 1910-11 1909-10 OmerD. Bones City Salesman, Armour & Company, beef and provision packers, northwest corner of 4th and Brazos Streets. The address is not listed in the directory. NOTE: Omer D. Bones is listed as the city salesman for Armour & Company, and resided at 401 E. 1st Street. 1- I it 0 -3 The 1922 Sanborn map shows the house at 1107 W. 9th Street (third lot from the right). The map shows the wraparound porches across the front of the house and the east side facing Baylor Street, but no porch around the back of the house. The configuration of the bay window at the front is different from that shown on the 1935 map (below) and what appears today. PS W4(S /1 /1 5:3 is The 1935 Sanborn map shows the house at 1107 W. 9:r Street with a wraparound porch around the front and east sides of the house and a small inset porch on the back of the house. The map also shows the current configuration of the bay window on the top left corner of the house footprint shown here. — - ii. M BIOGRAPHICAL NOTES Omer D. Bones (first owner) (1872- 1941) Omer D. Bones appears in the 1900 U.S. Census with his wife Pearl. They lived at the home of her mother, Mary Leonard, at 96 Trinity Street. Omer Bones worked in the grocery business. The 1910 U.S. Census shows Omer 0. Bones and his family living at 1107W. 9Th Street. Omer Bones was married to Pearl; they had 2 sons, Shirley and Vinson. Omer Bones was then 37 years old and had been born in Missouri. Pearl Bones was 34, and had been born in Texas to Virginia-born parents. Shirley was 5; Vinson was 3. Both boys had been born in Texas. Omer D. Bones was listed as working for a packing company. Bones does not appear in the 1920 U.S. Census for Travis County. By 1930, he was married to a woman named Louise, who had been born in Oregon. They were living on the grounds of the Austin State School, where they rented a house for $25 a month. Omer Bones was an accountant at the State School; Louise was a seamstress for the school. Omer Bones died in November, 1941 at the age of 69. His obituary in the Austin American stated that he had been the storekeeper for the Austin State School for 25 years and had been a resident of Austin br 60 years. He had been a deacon of the Central Christian Church. He had three sons, Miles Cary Bones of Austin, ES. (probably Shirley) Bones of Houston, and F.V. (probably Vinson) Bones, of Dallas. Among his honorary pallbearers were J.R Reed, of the music store on Congress, Judge J.D. Moore, Theo Davis, the son of wholesale grocer Nelson Davis, whose business was in the current Spaghetti Warehouse, Adolph Goldmann, the manager of Nelson Davis, and F.W. Sternenberg, the president of a large lumber company here in Austin. he Morturny n. sown 0. o: 4 *5 7’Ei e. (or I,. I .‘ aepcsha A,’d,n loese hç’.pkd at Thund.y Mr. Bo had bee a. AuI taidad f ‘t. R&. the Ctck 4’? at wa a member Chriam *t ed Ia.I4 e.:4 dncaa in the dnira. -w b wIde. one na fl e*a.( 4.UflL t S. — € . of Roino end F. V. Sa of DeI. . i . ‘.w. U. I Ran 4. San AnLc.,Jo: Bones of Arlington end Xci Scs of Sal. Antoam. LuMfal will be onth.ctM e the Thr Wtvd flEonmj hoe at I a flL. ci dip —ith burial ía Oakwood . two toIa1, . — nl services for 0. 1). Bon, I .,fl stJajl tar thcpeLvt [V e oxü*ucIed Friday it the — Weed Vuner.I borne with Satin Barclay oflkbth.s. ‘ :t 9. Wultiasthoen ‘Th WstkJaa. On Smith an Obituary of O.D. Bones Austin American, November 29, 1941 LII - ..— flcnorar jiillbernt wdrw xwre. I I *t 1, Neon. I It flat. Suds Ray: .4 krcsft: Judte S. .P Moe. te- ta4ia, JthIL Cud well. n A, GoI&z.iia and 7. V. Sinrcbfl Obituary of O.D. Bones Austin American, November 28, 1941 The Stokes Family John F. Stokes (1844- 1908) Julia (Mrs. John F.) Stokes (1849- 1934 Edward W. Stokes (1908 - 1961 Ruby Brewer Stokes (1886- 1945) Jewel Thomason Stokes (1895- 1996 The 1900 U.S. Census shows the Stokes family living in rural eastern Travis County. John F. Stokes was a 55-year old English-born rubber stamp maker; he and his wife Julia had 6 children, the youngest son being Edward, who was then 16. The 1910 U.S. Census shows Julia Stokes still residing in eastern Travis County with daughters Agnes, Annie, and Julia. Julia Stokes was working as a seamstress at home. Agnes Stokes worked as a saleslady at a dry goods store; Annie Stokes worked as a tailor at a department store. Young Julia Stokes had no occupation listed. E. W. Stokes does not appear in the 1910 Census report. The 1920 U.S. Census shows Edward and Ruby Stokes at 1107W. 9 Street. With them lived Edward’s mother Julia, and Edward’s sister Agnes, who worked as an alterations clerk at a department store. The city directories confirm that Agnes Stokes worked at Scarbrough’s as a seamstress. Edward Stokes is listed as a cashier for an express company. The city directories list him as the cashier for American Railway Express Company. The 1930 U.S. Census shows the Stokes family at 1107W. 9 Street, a house which they owned, and which was worth $4,500. Edward Stokes had been born in Texas; his wife Ruby had been born in Arkansas; his mother Julia had been born in Texas to German-born parents; his sister Agnes had been born in Texas. Edward Stokes was then 45 and working as a cashier at an express company; Ruby was 41; Julia was 81, and Agnes was 52, and working as a seamstress at a department store (Scarbrough’s). Edward’s father, John F. Stokes (who never lived in this house), died in June, 1908 He had lived in Austin for 40 years and passed away at his home near Govalle. He had been born in the Shetland Islands in 1844, where his father was stationed as the Wesleyan Methodist minister that year. He came to Austin in 1867, married Julia Wilhelm in 1871, and had six children. Edward’s mother Julia died in December, 1934. Her obituary stated that she was the mother of Ed W. Stokes, ‘for many years cashier of the express company here. Julia died at the house. She was one of Austin’s oldest natives, having been born in Austin in 1849, and had lived in Austin her entire life. She had been a member of the First Presbyterian Church. Ruby Stokes died at the house in 1945. Her obituary in the Austin Statesman related that she was then 59, and had lived in Austin since 1909. She was a member of the First Methodist Church. Edward remarried, to Jewel Thomason, who survived him when he passed away in 1961. His obituary in the Austin American stated that he was a lifetime resident of Austin, a member of the First Methodist Church, a member of the Austin Lodge No. 12, kF. & A.M., and had worked for many years as a cashier for the Railway Express Company. Jewel Stokes lived to be 101; she died in 1996, and had worked in the office of Woolworth’s for 45 years. ,4 A’to*n: % Stthin, 5$, reel, % 1900. died at hi Ni4th. Friday S. Is macviva fl t lW Stakes: 13 Board. ‘ It. fl irti Mr.. Ob rn I Fir , I tr 20 peal Pt nit ibe? of the O. ae4 ( Methodist se body is at I’u eral hone Whir. ire will probab)y be Su. tat will be 1 çn Obituary of Ruby Stokes Austin Statesman, June 2, 1945 ill ‘ r. ‘. S1’I)KF24 E XV, Stokek 1107 West 9th, nt tiled at J,1* hone Tursdny, lie 1. wa a lifetime reskient of AuMtn,1’ a niemFy’’ Gr the FNrs( Methcxlist (lurch, a member of Austin i ,nde Nor 12 A.F.&A.M., and tot ‘e miny veary was cuishier for the s- Railway Express compnrty before eht’i ttflWfltr’-.’.—--’-—-_-_._.__ — tin, Survivors are hLq widow 01 two nieces nnd three nephews.) :1 Funeral senqres will be he’d at TtWe eirto r I &flinéTif bout “Thursday at ‘2 p.m. Dr. Marvin Vunee wiN officiate and burial will, R be in Memorial Park under aus- IC piccs of Austifl Lodge No, 12 cli — Obituary of Edward W. Stokes Austin American, March 1, 1961 — I JOHN PCTOKEL t;tan, .1 AU.tSn tsr Past Fay Vein I.0 He Is Sn” P sto...adt1sa of A..tIl. tot*Y 7fl. p.004 aw.Y TOT ‘the 3,1st i.E Mt home ner Gonii yet.rd*y by . oorflltj widow ROd s1 çhfldfn. FInIVOI Ian hrs* wW be troui hi. iMe teosdan niL at the city. oofld’.cted by P... Dr. A. F. B5b0D. paste. of the fleet Pits hl.I bflerlan thurch. at It o’clock menbt. Jan. IL •@rvt’ad M’. States was bait Ia the Sfltlat4 Ia 1U4. whets hiS tamer was hand. .IItIncd as its. WesI.yaa 3t.t)*,diit. niInII’n U; that y.*r. Mr St,hn eel- ti_I. In Au.et:n in lIST, .04 Was mat- risC to $ln lull. WUbsIth in i.;z. a. fll.g lb. ,unleItg wt4w, Tb. sur’ itlifl ebllrwn •te two as. cbni - sod Edwr4, abA fiir 4atei* El- OW ohs I i.p, ‘f.tlltr’II amity titers sowive hI’S thea aroItrs an’S tea stwtna. 1 at rndLng In flgIso wtth It. tact? S tlor. Lt his tnsb.r ReT7, W tilisso of AIICI. AaSIe Slid Jofla. IS Obituary of JohnRStokes Austin Statesman, June 23, 1908 (inCh, Suliday. aO’t. d. I. nflto.d by STOKKS—3Irt Jgia W. 5toke moo’s, of Ed W. Stolcee, for manY Ynn a.h*r nt the axorea. no’S f..y bne. dlt t th. flnrfi’ bee 1It West ascii. hat IWO dallfltfl. Salt. Ii B, OtT..bç •±td gin Avis. SidIw tour r.n lea.. two gr.nd,Iabflt.n enS nra gflai-flnddaflbier,.11 of ku.Iill. Mr. Stoke, so en. of Austin. nldni n.13v, bs.lng been born 1 Liii, aid had Iteid his’s M• PQt wy ,...n bet. all bsr lift sb. ‘n. I biembe of Os. fleet PrabyterAn chtmrr.b, — a’n ,wnlcnss. J1d at lb -ir is rarMondii Tb. Rn Dojel t flt4- nffl.Ifl,q daê na siestaS by lb. Rn-.. VIrtli 74. FIsher. Dqtt& ni Is OthwoadSaetny — Obituary of Mrs. Julia Stokes Austin Statesman, December 24, 1934 yeara tOt bias. .flT re. iflWfl 3701 n. a! viol-h at! dun Mrs. 5uby Srtwer Stakn 5, rnideot i,t tI. ted at her hokne a I lOX West 7(intb Fri day nighi. She is sun wed by her husband, F. W. Stpked: three sisters. Mn. t B Bo*rd, Wt it l&ho, Mrs. W. W. flflm4n Spri atcid. Ma.. and Ma )daggir Spasm Ps,4.,u. VMS, The Wdy ‘t t the Wnd-.CarIey pending ftmnnd a- dop ‘fey nngtmwta Funeral horn :0 Obituary of Ruby Stokes Austin American, June 2, 1945 - Jewefl Thoinason Sbus Jeweu Thomason Stokes, age 101, 01 Austin died a; her home on Thursdey, January 11, 1996 She was ar office manapr ac Wool worths f- 45 year%. She was preceded in death b her two shuns: hushend. Edwerd Stokes: - h and itac-w tnt S.-vwocs ucIude Per sntn. VoIei MaLcn and Juanita fleming and sever u a) ruees and ne S Mrs. Stokes will lie In aaie al sr home. fines-al services will be t.ld at I0) am. Monday at 1107 West 9th St tha 10, AustLn Graveslde savica ww be h ml. ; lI ajn. Monday. in Au,tIn Memo WI, rest-nephews wLJj serve as rialtark her paLlbearers Arrangements by WeedCorleyJish Pwwnl Nome. 3125 K Lamar. 4o3-$I I ok vu- of Obituary of Jewell Stokes Austin American-Statesman January 13, 1996 ______ _______ __________________ __________ _____ ____ CITY OF AUSTIN PLANNING DEVELOPMENT AND REVIEW DEPARTMENT A. APPLICATION FOR HISTORIC ZONING PROJECT INFORMATION: DEPARTMENTAL USE ONLY 4W’ APPLICATION DATE:C’i Qfl F TENTAT1VEHLC DATE: TENTATIVE PC or ZAP DATE:______________ TENTATIVE CC DA CASE MANAGER APPLICATION I FILE NUMBER(S) ; r I C- Cx, CITY INITIATED YES/NC ROLLBACK: YES/NO BASIC PHOJtCI tiArA: ‘ 1 1. OWNER’S NAMEA I hr± j.ferciefir. Aa.JO( k W1J C.. 2PROJECTNAME.MLs — S4t L<ec. 3PROJECTSTREETADDRESS(orRange); -4nse... .Jt.+ ZIP 3-( 3Q_ COUNTY: Tr*s IF PROJECT ADDR!SS CANNOT SE DEFINED ABOVE: lOCATED 11 ‘- ke . .,. FRONTAGE FLETALONG THE N. S F W (CIRCLE ONE) SIDEOF (ROAD NAME PROPERTY FRONTS ONTO). WHICH IS APPROXIMATFI V INTERSECTONW TH ., AREATOBERZGNE&’ \“‘ . . - DISTANCE FROM ITS CROSS STREET. Ti?-L 4 Cj1 L4A ii 4. ACRES (OR) SQ,FT111L C 5. ZONING AND LAND USE INFORMATION; EXISTING ZONING 5r-3MP EXISTING USE c4sicc T9ACT4 (IF MORE THAN ) M/A ACRES!SO FT. PRO2OSEO USE ‘ 714 .d33 kc5(eIcMC4- PROPOSED ZONING Sr -jW RELATED CURRENT CASES: 1°. SITE PLAN? - (YES 0 FILE NUMBEPz Updated October 13, 2009 7 ____________________________________ ____________________________ ____________________ ______________ _____-— __________________________________________ ____________________ ____ ____________ ____ ___ CITY OF AUSTIN PLANNING DEVELOPMENT AND REVIEW DEPARTMENT PROPERTY DESCRIPTION (SUBDIVISION REFERENCE OR METES AND BOUNDS): ba. SUBDMSION REFERENCE. Name: Block(s) A Plat Book Number. Lot(s L? eL Page lOb. METES AND BOUNDS (Attach two copies ul cer.died field notes ;f suhd!is on references rot ava’ aSic or pP 4s _PLtt+_KecorAs of Vt ib.As Co.s.4 Tt.,c, 1 29 cIiv5go Outlet(s) — 1 DtLN$(6aj . zoning includes partial lots) DEED REFERENCE CONVEYING PROPERTY TO PRESENT OWNER AND TAX PARCEL .0.: It VOLUME_I31j_pAG:, 549 — TPARCELID L —— ffk-4 2ooc31L %j..T5929 a OTHER PROVISIONS: 12. IS PROPERTY IN A ZONING COMBINING DISTRICT e OVERLAY ZONE? YES TYPE Of COMBINING DISTIOVERIAY ZONE NCCONP. elc) 13. LOCATED IN A LOCAL OR NATIONAL REGIS ER HISIORIC DISTRICT? (W?j NO VsJcs4— i’—’c. iv R I4DI 14. Is A flA REQUIRED? yrs TRIPS PER DAY: TRAFfICSERIALZONEtS) (NOT REQUIRED IF BASE ZONING IS NItHANGING) OWNERSHIP TYPE: 15. SOLE COMMUNITY PROPERTY PARTNERSHIP CORPOIR1 ION TRUST II ownership is other than sole or conitvun:ty property, fist :ndividuals/partnerslpr nepals below or attacI separate sheet. _AtL?sc-:uL 41%JD( k VtbJ C. 4c3 c5_ — OWNER INFORMATION: 16. OWNER - - — ti/k FIRM NAME: $REETADDRESS___LJ___J)ti-..... CITY - A S#iaJ EMALADDRESS: C3.actCJmsakeS o,nC. Con STATE. — NAML: kCJ1.C. K5Lcs TLLLPHONFNUMBER-SLL 6 -cC1 ZIP oobE—T_5-w- - -- — - .4ct,( m s&c c i CONTACT INF RMATION - p” SIGNATURE: FIRM NAME: STREET ADDRESS: CITY: ,4’.-’s4r,n 4- gin . (,J. °I+I..... STATE: tic EMAILADRESS: tL &C+_ C,htIhI DEPARTMENTAL USE ONLY: Updated October 13 20D9 NAME: A- Lba-± tJPec CLIIA, TELEPHONE NUMBER: I F - ZIPCODE:S9O3 TEUJUI.flI... TIUM8& 2) e.Jkp .efl a ___________________ ______ ______ __ ______ ___ _______ _______ ____ CITY OF AUSTIN PLANNING OEVELOPMENT AND REVIEW DEPARTMENT D. SUBMITTAL VERIFICATION AND INSPECTION AUTHORIZATION SUBMITTAL VERICATION My signature attests to the tact the attached appliciibon package is complete and accurate to the best of my I understand that proper City staff revew of this apphcation s dependent upon the accuracy of tne information knowledge. provided and that any inaccurate or nadquate infour:a:ion provded by rneimy firm!etc., may delay the proper review of this apolication that PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT NAME BELOW SIGNATURE AND INDICATE FIRM REPRESENTED, IF APPLICABLE. Scj Albert A)frfc Date Signature kcyi,J C Name (Typed or Printed) Firm (If applicable) INSPECTION AUTHORIZATION As owner or authorized agent, my signature authari7es staff to visit and inspect the property for which this application is being subntttu’J. PLEASE TYPE OR PRINT NAME BELOW SIGNATURE AND INDICATE _LIRP&REP&FPLlC ESENTED I ABLE. Signature C Ht Name (Typed or Printed3 Firm (If applicable) ate — Updated October 13. 2009 c4C0 g CITY OF AUSTIN PLANNING DEVELOPMENT AND REVIEW DEPARTMENT E. ACKNOWLEDGMENT FORM concerning Subdivision Plat Notes, Deed Restrictions. Restrictive Covenants and I or Zoning Conditional Overlays I A ih + E. ?trcc.Ia.( restrictions, CPdr name of appltari) frt’4p1 have checked for subdvision plat notes, deed restrictive covenants and/or zoning conditional overlays prohibiting certain uses and/or requiring certain development restrcrions i.e. height, access, screening etc. on this property, located at LO- cJ, 94- A..s4ni YA -:Iy93 ACcess or Legal Dcscip!ion) If a conflict snould result with the request I am submitting to the City of Austin due to subdivision plat notes. deed restrictions, restrictive covenants and/or zoning conditional overlays it will be my responsibility to resolve I also acknowledge that I understand the implications of use and/or development restrictions that are a it. resuli of a subdivision plet notes, deed restrictions, restrictive covenants and/or zoning conditional overlays. I understand that if requested I ciust provide copies of any and all subdivision plat notes, deed restrictions, restrictive covenants and/or zoning conditional overlay information which may apply to this property. (Appllcnnrs sIgnature4/f,c÷ a ?eccij4-( s//c / i ‘(Date) ker.i C. s ijoijated October 13. 2009 eXit ____ TAX CERTIFICATE Nelda Wells Spears Tra,±s County ‘rax Assessor-Collt.jtor P.O. Box 1748 Austin Texas 78767 C51) 854-9473 - NO 1055503 ACCOUNT NUMBER: 01-0901--041l-0000 PROPERTY OWNER: PERCIVAL ALBERT E III & KEVIN CHUCK HUGHES 113/ W 9TH ST AUSTIN, TX 78703-4925 PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: LOT 0 ED 81.1< A OLT 2 DIV Z RAYMOND S’J ACRES .0000 MIN% 000000000000 TYPE 1107 SITUS INFORNATION: This is to certify that after a careful cheCk of tax records of this office, following taxes, delinquent taxes, penalties and interests are due on the described property of the following tax units) YEAR 2009 AUSTIN ISD ENTITY W 9 ST the TOTAL CITY OF AUSTIN (TRAy) TRAVIS COUNTY TRAInS COUNTY HEALTHCARE DISTRICT ACC (TRAVIS) AIJL PAID ALL PAID* *ALL PAID* ALL PAID* ALL PA1D TOTAL SEQUENCE 0 TOTAL TAX: UNPAID FEES: INTEREST ON FEES: COMMISSION: TOTAL DUE > ALL PAID* •ALL PAID NONE * * NONE * * NONE * * tALL PAID* $9,3O.74 TAXES PAID FOR YRAP. 2009 ALL TAXES PAID IN FULL PRIOR TO AND INCLUDING THE YEAR 2009 EXCEPT FOR UNPAID YEARS LISTED ABOVE. The above described property nay be subject o spec-ial valuation based on its use, and additional ro1bac taxes may become due. Proçerty Tax Code) Pursuant to Section 31.00 of the State Property Tax (‘r,de, $10.00 for all Tax Certificates. GIVEN UNDER MY HAND AND SEAL OF OFFICE ON THIS DATE OF 05/18/2010 Sect1on 23.55, Sta:e there is a fee of Fee Paid: $10.00 Nelda Wells Spears Tax Assessor-Collector By - — ARROYCA printed on 05/18/2010 14:41:22;05 Pagefr q,cr The Bones-Stokes House 1107 V• 9th Street Built: 1909 ARCHITECTURE OF THE HOUSE The building of this house ‘vts completed around Septeniber 1909 by Calcasicu Lumber Company, and is an excellent example of the transition in residential architecture from Victorian houses of the late 19th century to the bungalows of the iQ2Us. the house is one-and-a-half stories with a hipoed roof, hipped donners. and a wraparound porch, Porches were a very imporiant lëaiurc of houses built in the days before every house had electricity. In the sumner, people would spend a lot of time on the porch because it was too hot in the house, so the porch was not only functional, hut a social area as well. This house faces north, which made the porch a comfortable social area away from the heat of the sun, Above the front door there is a transom, and this was an integral part of architecture of the period as well — these transoms could be opened to provide air circulation within the house without having to have the front door open. The house still has 7 working transoms throughout the inside, which helped to circulate the air between rooms. even with the doors closed. Transitional houses such as this one represent the beginning of the change from Victorians with ornate decoration to simple hungalows. At the turn of the 20th centu’, the big Victorian houses were falling out of popular taste because of’ their over-indulgence in architectural ornamentation. When you think of big Victorian houses. )Ou think of titrrut, leaded glass, fish-scale shingles. and other ways of ornamenung the house. Transitional houses marked a change — they backed away l’roin such a high degree of ornamentation. and also presented a sinipler. more functional floorplan. ‘Ibis was the fourth house built on this side of 9th street between ltiylcr and Illanco. lhe first house was IIII W 9th. which still stands. It was owned by James 1-1. Hubbard. who was the secretary and treasurer of the Austin Transfer Company, a railn’ad warehousing tin_n. By 1909, the hcusc next door (to rite west - 1 l09 htxl been built by August l3rill. who was a saddle and buggy manufacturer. Vhere the apartment cempiex is now (1115) was another pre-1910 house. this one owned by James McNarnara. who with his brother, had a candy factory here in Austin. [hat house was torn down in 1966 and the apanntent complex was built in 1977. This area was developed quickly and attracted the upper middle class to its hilltop location on the western edge or the city. The families who bought houses in this block included the proprietor of a dry goods store on 6 Street (Shelby house at 1114 W. 9th), the city salesman fbr a wholesale grocery company, and a wholesale produce merchant, all men who had either established their own businesses or had dsen to the top of their line of work. ‘The house at 1107 Vest gill Street has had a number of changes over the years. fhe house first appears on the L922 Sanborn Fire Insurance (‘onipany map. and shows a smaller Footprint than exists today. The original house had a porch stretching all the way across the front of tite house and another one along the east side. i’here was no back perch. Between 1922 arid L935, design of the house was modified to include a ha’ window, extend the sides of the hous 4 C’— back and include a small porch in the middle of the back of the house. In 1962. the house was modified again — the hay window was brought forward a few feet onto the porch to create a larger living room inside — which eliminated the front porch in front of this window, and the back part of the side porch was enclosed to enlarge the bedroom. In 200L the kitchen at the back of the house was extended slightly to the rear (‘tim Cuppelt was the architect for this In 2010 the front porch was restored to again extend all the way across the tont of the project). house (and free one of the original porch pillars from the wall built in 1962) by moving a modified version of the hay window back (tim Cuppett was also the architect for this project). All of the finishes and details on the outside of the house are original. with the exception of (he new bay ‘sindow. HISTORY OF [HE HOUSE Interestingly. in 1910, Bones’ boss. l’hc (bt owner at this house was ()mcr 0. Hones and his faniily. Mr. Hones vats the city salesrntm for Armour and Company, which was a beef packing house at 4” and Brains Street. dv 1912. he was working for Swift and Company at 311 Conc’rcss Avenue (shere the ELephant Room is now I honias Jervis, the manager of Armour & Company. lised at 1115 W 9th Street, where the apartment complex is now. Hones and his wife Pearl lived here until around 1914. wlen they moved to 3903 4venue I), and he went into the gmcery business with Walter ii. Morris at 2520-22 Guadalupe Street. EerTtiihly, ()ri’er Bones became the storekeeper for the Austin State School. a posilicin he held for 25 years. His second wife, Louise, was a searnslress at the state school. 1)mer Bones sold the house to Edward W. Stokes, who had hen a traveling saicsman for a wholesale grocen company called W.13. Walker and Sons. Fthard Stokes had lived with his thrnilv in the Govalle area of East Austin before moving into this house. His father, John Stoke5, was an English-born rubber stamp manufacturer, and had died the same year Edward was born. Edward, his mother Julia, and his sister Agnes moved into this tiouse front their house in Govalle. He was a tra-ching salesman for a wholesale grocery company, and in 191 S. lie went to work flit lie was a cashier or several raihwa c.picsS companies until his retirement. His mother, the former Julia Wilhelm. had been born in Austin in 1849 and lived She pissed away in 1934. His sister Agnes was a seamstress for here her entire life- Scarbrough’s Department Store downtown for marty years. Edward Stokes must have had an attraction to gemstones — his first wife was named Ruby, and his second witë was named Jewel, After Ed Stokes died in 1961. Jewel continued to Live here and was tO! when she passed away in \VeIIs Fargo. Ihe current owners of the house are Albert ii. Percival and Kevin Chuck Hughes. HISTORIC CHARACTERISTICS OF THE HOUSE As described above, (l)the house is 100 plus years old; (2) the front exterior of the house retains sufficient integrity of materials and design to convey’ fls historic appearance: within the Westline NRHD; (4) the house has distinguishing characteristics of a rec architectural style (transition in residential architecture from Victorian houses of th (.4) the hous’ 9th century to the bungalows of the 1920s), the property has unique physical characteristics that represent an established and familiar visual feature of the Old West Austin neighborhood. which contributes to the character and image of the City of Austin. cc,b __________ _______________ ______________ ________________ ______________________ _______________ [ii4irntorJSEate oil’exa.s - -_____________ - 1X49 1R49 GraMee: James H. Raymond Instrument: Patent No. 140 Volume 2 General Land Office. Book D, Page 1 29-30 Travis County Date of Instrument: October 16, J$4X File Date: March 6, 1349 Grantor: James H. Raymond and wife Margaret 1. Grantee: Thomas T. Fauntleroy Instrument: Quit Claim Deed. Book B, Page 489-490 Travis County Date of Instrument: January 11. 1849 File Date: JaniJ5.i!4.9 - - - -— 1849-1897 Grantor: Thomas T. Fauntleroy. of the United States Army Grantee; James H. Raymond and wife Margaret 1, Instrument: Quit Claim Deed, Rook 0, Page 30-31 Travis County Date of Instrument: February 23, 1849 File Date: March 6 1X49 - 18Q7-1901 Grantor: Estate ofiamesil. Raymond. Deceased Grantee: numerous heirs as part of an estate valued at approximately SI 58,000 Instrument: Probated Will, Recorded Minutes, Book 10. Page 228, Travis (:000iv Date of Instrument: June 20, 1891 (date of Will) Date of Death: October 30, 1897 Probate Date: December 20, 1897 1901-1906 Grantor: James II. Raymond, Jr. et al 1906- 1909 1909-1913 Grantee: G.M. Brass Instrument: Special Warranty Deed. Book 171. Page 212-2:14, Travis (:nFintv Date of Instrument: January 26. 1901 File Date: March 21. 1 901 (;rantor: tiM, Brass and wife (;rantec: 4W. BrilI Instrument; Warranty Deed, Book 207, Page 300, l)ate of instrument: February 21, 1906 File Date: February 24, 190(3 Grantor: 4W. Bill) and Wife Ida Brill Grantee: 0.1). Bones and Perle Bones Instrument: Warranty Deed, Hook 234. Page 53-54. Travis County Date of Instrument June 1, 109 File Date: June 1, 1909 Building Contract: l’lw original house was built pursuant to a contract dated July 16, 1909 between Calcasieu I. umber Company and Of). Bones and Wife. This coutmet required delivery of the house by September 13, 1909. Calcasicu Lumber Company sold the related note to W.S. Drake, l’ravis County 1: ___________ ______-. ___ _____ _______ _______ _____________ ___________ ___________ ____ _____ who tiled a related Lien on December 19, 1910, Book 244, Page 10-13, IravisCouny 1911.-I 935 Grantor: OJ), Bones and Pearle Bones urantce: Julia Sin kes Instrument: Warranty Deed, I3ook 257, Page 58. Travis County Date of Instrument: May 12. 913 File Date: May 12, 1913 1935-1961 Grantor: Julia Stokes Grantee: Edward W. Stokes Instrument: Probated Will. Recorded Minutcs. Book 78, Page 381 -383. Travic County Date of Instrument: I Jnknown (dait of Will) Date of Death: February 13, 1935 i9ol-1996 Grantor: Edward W. Stokes 1996 Grantee: Ilessie Jewell Thomason Stokes, widow of Edward W. Stukc5 Instrument: Texas laws of Intestate, no will found Date of Death: Fehnnrs 28, 1 9(’J Date of Transfer: February 2S. I (;rnntor F3essie Jewell Thoniason Stokes, Deceased and Juanita Thomajon Fleming Grantee: Dale M. Sengclrnann. Milton and Joan T. Sengelmann Instrument: General Warranty Deed, flock 13686, Page 1521 l)ate of Instrument: May 14, 1996 196 - 1996-1999 Grantor: Milton and Joan I. Sengelmann Grantee: Dale M. Sengelmann Instrument: Quit Claim Deed, Book 12834, Page 559 Datc of Instrument: [Jecember 13, 1996 File Date: December 13, 1996 1999-2005 Grantor: Dales Sengelmann Grantee; Dale Sengelmann and Albert Percival Instrument: Warranty Deed, l3ook I 33X1, Page 549 Date of Instrument: March 3, 1999 File Date: March 3, 1999 j Grantor: Dale Sengelmiurn and Albert Percival Grantee: Albert Percival and Kevin Chuck Hughes Instrument: Warranty Deed, Document Number: 2005216482 I)ate of Instrument: November 2, 2005 2005- Present L_J_!j!ea!tqvernbcr2,2005 . —--.-,—.--—-—--—-—,-----____ ! . ! ! M v 0 : q ’ 4 — I O _ I I. — — —I The ca. 1909 A.W. and Ida Brill house located nest door to the west at 1109W. 9 Street. The Brills sold the property at 1107W. 9th Street to Omer and Pearl Bones in 1909. Both houses were built that same year.