13 C14H-2022-0099 - Delisle House; District 10 Part 2.pdf — original pdf
Backup
Bridge (Southside of property) Bench (South of primary residence) Historic Preservation Office, 2022 Occupancy History City Directory Research, March 2022 C. H. and Mildred E. Slator, owners Lawyer 1211 Perry-Brooks building C. H. and Mildred E. Slator, owners Lawyer 1211 Perry-Brooks building C. H. and Mildred E. Slator, owners Lawyer 1211 Perry-Brooks building C. H. and Mildred E. Slator, owners Lawyer 1211 Perry-Brooks building C. H. and Mildred E. Slator, owners Lawyer 709 Littlefield building 1947 Address not listed 1959 1957 1955 1952 1949 Aerials 1940 Aerial 1977 Aerial Permits 1977 Aerial Water service permit, 1951 Building permit, 1949 Fehr & Granger Stamp Fehr & Granger remodel plans, date. Fehr & Granger remodel plans. Fehr & Granger remodel plans. Timeline of Raymond Delisle family The Corpus Christi Caller Times: Sunday August 20, 1944. Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Ila Falvey Monday, May 2, 2022 8:22 AM HPD Preservation Case number: GF22-047398-2002 Scenic Dr *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Attn: Amber Allen Thank you for your research on the property. In addition to the attributes that you mentioned, this building contributes to the neighborhood of rock houses that are common in the area and represent an era of Austin's past. This neighborhood's importance was emphasized as it and several of the rock houses were included on Preservation Austin's Home Tour in 2010. I strongly oppose destroying an historic house, the long two story rock house with the whimsical carved keystones, and the bridges and paths that meander through the property. This property is a treasure and should be respected for its beauty not destroyed to maximize wealth. Ila Falvey CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 1 Laura Des Enfants 3706 Stevenson Avenue Austin TX 78703 x During this period of rapid growth Austin needs to be vigilant and preserve its architectural history or risk losing both its character and history. 5.2.2022 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Meredith Dreiss Monday, May 2, 2022 2:07 PM HPD Preservation case # GF22-047398-2002 Scenic Dr *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Case # GF 22‐047398‐2002 Scenic Dr Dear Amber Allen, I am writing in hopes that a hold can be put on demolition plans for 2002 Scenic Drive, Austin, TX 78703 until further research can be completed by the city’s historic preservation department. I currently live down the street from 2002 Scenic Dr at 3002 Scenic, but before moving I lived across the street from 2002 Scenic at 3805 Stevenson Avenue for 29 years. I’ve been inside 2002 on a number of occasions during the years that Whit and Allison Hanks rented the house from owners C.H. and Mildred Slator. 2002 Scenic is extremely unique with whimsical nooks and crannies, spectacular stone fireplaces and a stone façade that seems more “rustic stone vernacular” than Spanish Colonial revival. What’s more important to think about is its contextual setting: Where Stevenson Avenue dead ends into Scenic Drive right at the cliff overlooking Lake Austin, there are 7‐8 adjacent stone house built in the 1930s and early 40s that are similar and may have been designed by the same architect. For example, I know the fireplaces at both 2002 Scenic and 3805 Stevenson (across the street) were probably built by the same stone mason, both are highly unusual and quirky with similar elements. I believe this grouping of houses could be considered an historic district and should be assessed accordingly. Having walked Scenic Drive for 43 years I’ve also noticed traces of archaeological chert‐working where Scenic and Stevenson streets meet. I know this kind of evidence does not necessarily halt demolition permits, but just wanted to mention it. I’ve read that the earliest city records date to 1946 when the architectural firm of Fehr and Granger were hired by the Slators for renovations. I’ve had trouble finding out who the original architect was and what the house may have looked like before renovations, but tax records indicated construction date may be 1930. Arthur Fehr worked for architect Harvey P. Smith of San Antonio during this time. Smith was renowned for mission and restoration work and some of Smith’s Spanish Colonial style architecture is reminiscent of 2002 Scenic and also next door at 2008 Scenic (built in 1935) as well as across the street at 2005 Scenic (built in 1930). I’m not saying Smith was the architect, but I am guessing that he may have been, and perhaps it’s the reason Fehr and Granger were hired 16 years later to work on the house renovations. Before Arthur Fehr partnered with Charles Granger Jr. in the mid 1940s becoming famous in Austin for their mid‐century modern churches, schools, and residences, Fehr work for the National Park Service as architect and furniture maker on a number of 1930 CCC buildings including Indian Lodge in Ft, Davis and Bastrop State Park that focused on using locally sourced materials. His notoriety alone should warrant careful consideration before any demolition permit is granted. There is no doubt in my mind that losing the house at 2002 Scenic Drive would be a huge loss to the neighborhood and to Austin. It is simply irreplaceable. Meredith Dreiss 1 CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 2 To: Amber Allen, Historic Preservation Office, City of Austin Re: Demolition of 2002 Scenic Drive (GF22-047398) Dear Ms. Allen 2 May 2022 As a former resident across the street from 2002 Scenic Drive, I would like to write a letter protesting its proposed demolition. While the building complex has fallen into disrepair in recent years, it is a unique surviving element of a small 1930s neighborhood anchored around what is today the corner of Scenic and Stevenson. While some of the early buildings are now gone or heavily remodeled, portions still remain of this once vibrant little block of dwellings. Built mostly in a rustic, limestone-based style, those remains are quite distinctive from the more recent contemporary styles being erected around it. The houses of that early era in West Austin had a warm, charming and almost magical feel to them, in direct contrast to the harder lines of the newer surrounding structures, and they bring a feeling to the little neighborhood that will be lost when 2002 Scenic and its still surviving early twentieth century neighbors are removed. I understand that 2002 Scenic was remodeled by Fehr and Granger in the late 1940s, a fact that supports its importance, and the need for preservation. Undertaken by two well-known veterans of Depression-era National Park Service construction, the 2002 Scenic remodel incorporates elements of Fehr’s earlier work at Bastrop State Park and seems to represent a stage in the transition of his own career from a more historical beaux arts/eclectic style to his later mid-century modern designs. Born in Austin, Fehr was important in introducing the mid-century modern design into Texas, and aspects of his historical oeuvre of structures should be considered important for protection in our rapidly changing world. I am an archaeologist with considerable experience in the historical era and some knowledge of historic structures. Though retired, I am still a research fellow at UT Austin. I have worked with the documentation and preservation of early buildings in Austin for decades and have sadly seen so many fine examples of past architectural styles demolished. We are too rapidly losing the anchor of our historic, architectural past, and it would be sad to see these once elegant structures removed. I am strongly in favor of refusing the demolition permit and seeking preservation partners to protect these impressive buildings. Thank you for your consideration in the matter. Sincerely, David O. Brown, Ph.D. Associate, Archeoproductions, Inc. To: Amber Allen, Historic Preservation Office, City of Austin Re: Demolition of 2002 Scenic Drive (GF22-047398) Dear Ms. Allen 2 May 2022 As a former resident across the street from 2002 Scenic Drive, I would like to write a letter protesting its proposed demolition. While the building complex has fallen into disrepair in recent years, it is a unique surviving element of a small 1930s neighborhood anchored around what is today the corner of Scenic and Stevenson. While some of the early buildings are now gone or heavily remodeled, portions still remain of this once vibrant little block of dwellings. Built mostly in a rustic, limestone-based style, those remains are quite distinctive from the more recent contemporary styles being erected around it. The houses of that early era in West Austin had a warm, charming and almost magical feel to them, in direct contrast to the harder lines of the newer surrounding structures, and they bring a feeling to the little neighborhood that will be lost when 2002 Scenic and its still surviving early twentieth century neighbors are removed. I understand that 2002 Scenic was remodeled by Fehr and Granger in the late 1940s, a fact that supports its importance, and the need for preservation. Undertaken by two well-known veterans of Depression-era National Park Service construction, the 2002 Scenic remodel incorporates elements of Fehr’s earlier work at Bastrop State Park and seems to represent a stage in the transition of his own career from a more historical beaux arts/eclectic style to his later mid-century modern designs. Born in Austin, Fehr was important in introducing the mid-century modern design into Texas, and aspects of his historical oeuvre of structures should be considered important for protection in our rapidly changing world. I am an archaeologist with considerable experience in the historical era and some knowledge of historic structures. Though retired, I am still a research fellow at UT Austin. I have worked with the documentation and preservation of early buildings in Austin for decades and have sadly seen so many fine examples of past architectural styles demolished. We are too rapidly losing the anchor of our historic, architectural past, and it would be sad to see these once elegant structures removed. I am strongly in favor of refusing the demolition permit and seeking preservation partners to protect these impressive buildings. Thank you for your consideration in the matter. Sincerely, David O. Brown, Ph.D. Associate, Archeoproductions, Inc. Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: t wise Monday, May 2, 2022 5:07 PM HPD Preservation 2002 Scenic *** External Email ‐ Exercise Caution *** Dear Ms Allen, Thank you for your work in assessing the historical/architectural significance of this beautiful property. Please count me, neighbor since 1989, as one who strongly supports saving the home. Sincerely, Tracy Wise CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 1 Phil Gilbert 3805 Stevenson Ave. Austin, Texas 78703 May 3, 2022 City of Austin Residential Permitting To Whom It May Concern, Re: Objection to Complete Demolition of 2002 Scenic Drive, Austin, Texas I am opposed to the complete demolition of the house at 2002 Scenic Drive, Austin. I live across the street and while a complete demo and new build would no doubt be quicker, it is worth the time and effort to see that the essence of the beautiful, important structure(s) be built upon, not completely torn down. Austin offers a lot to the imagination. It’s that mythology, if you will, that is fueling our growth; it’s enticing hundreds of thousands to become new Austinites. That’s good. Bob Dylan wrote: “He not busy being born is busy dying.” Austin is constantly being born — from the 70’s “outlaws” that turned us into “the live music capital of the world” through to the 21st century technologists we are home to today. Change is good. But we must direct that change into something that is authentic. Something of Austin, not just in Austin. Change for change sake is childish… and change for convenience sake is even worse: it threatens the essence of the Austin ethic that is the wellspring for each renewal. The house at 2002 Scenic Drive is a great example of that weird, wonderful Austin ethic. It may be one of only a handful of remaining properties with this aesthetic. In fact, Scenic Drive itself is an Austin icon… and on Scenic there's only one other house that achieves the result of the house at 2002 Scenic — and it’s The Rock House, right next door. (It also has a colorful history… no doubt when Robert Redford was coming to play at his grandparents’ Rock House in those 1950’s summers he played with friends next door!) 1 2 of I won’t speak much about the specific architectural and design elements that can never be recreated except to say: why would we destroy these last of a kind works when there is no need? The exterior easily displays its uniqueness. But inside is where the magic truly happens. There are literally dozens of one-of-a-kind design elements that would be destroyed forever, if we allowed a total demolition. If you question their value, then go to the property to see them yourself! While we want growth, we surely don’t want indiscriminate and undifferentiated mansions that inspire nothing more than calculations of price per square foot and “oh my gosh what a view.” If you buy a property with this beauty, history and landmark location I would hope you pay homage to it, restoring and renovating it into a modern expression of itself. I hope the house at 2002 Scenic is restored and renovated into a new architectural masterpiece that will inspire citizens 100 years from today to fight for it, as we fight for this 100 year old masterpiece. I strongly urge the City to reject the complete demolition of 2002 Scenic Drive. I also urge the City to approve any limited demolition only with simultaneous approval of the new home to be built, so that the essence of the property can be assured, prior to the demo of the old one. Sincerely yours, /s/ Phil Gilbert cc: Mayor Pro-Tem Alison Alter 2 2 of Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Ben Noelke Tuesday, May 3, 2022 3:13 PM HPD Preservation Case number: GF22-047398-2002 Scenic Dr *** External Email ‐ Exercise Caution *** We oppose the demolition. It would be a real shame to lose it. Please at least consider saving the structure to the north (non main house). Ben Noelke 2107 Scenic Drive Sent from my iPad CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 1 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: birgit birgite.com Tuesday, May 3, 2022 4:03 PM HPD Preservation birgit birgite.com Case number: GF 22-047389 (2002 Scenic Drive) *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Preservation Team ‐ A neighbor from my previous neighborhood of Matthews and Stevenson alerted me to the request to demolish 2002 Scenic. This property was the location for several neighborhood Holiday parties when the property was rented to Whit and Allison Hanks. Whit was friends with one of the Slator's and was able to rent it. What a historic location for neighborhood events!! It was at this location in 1997 or so that I had a conversation with Tito Beveridge about his plans for the future. He said "I"m starting a vodka company." My response "Good luck with that!" The rest is history. The wonderful Scottie Stevenson was in attendance at these Holiday parties. Dressed to the nines and every bit the former First Lady of Texas, Mrs. Stevenson was a delight to talk to and learn about her fascinating life. We'd all walk the one block to our houses together after the party concluded. https://www.dignitymemorial.com/obituaries/austin‐tx/edith‐stevenson‐8213422 My son, who is a stone carver, woodworker and artist commented that many of the staircases on the property are carved into the rocks cascading down the hill. Very unusual to see that quality of workmanship these days. The entire property, with the triangular pool, changing rooms, greenhouse, stone bridge, pathways and numerous stone buildings, is a community treasure. Please do not grant the demolition permit. The property should be restored and preserved. Thank you for your consideration. Birgit Enstrom CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 1 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Flagged noreply@coadigital.onbehalfof.austintexas.gov on behalf of City of Austin <noreply@coadigital.onbehalfof.austintexas.gov> Wednesday, May 4, 2022 12:22 PM HPD Preservation GF22-047398-2002ScenicDr. This message is from Alison Hanks. [ ] To: AMBER ALLEN Attn: Amber Allen Re: 2002 Scenic Dr. Case GF22‐047398‐2002ScenicDr. Greetings. I'm Alison Hanks and I lived at 2002 Scenic from 1996‐2004. Debbie Slator Gillan, landlady, grew up there and told me many things about the house. I also conducted oral histories with the owners of the other 'rock houses' in the area. C.H. and Mildred Slator bought the house in 1947. It remained in the Slator family until sold last year. The house was built by Raymond Maurice Delisle in the 1920s. (Wife‐Ammon McGaughey Delisle.) His artistry can be seen in exterior and interior carvings of animals, clowns, shamrocks, elephant, box of matches and cigar, nude woman, and a mural covering all the walls of the upstairs bathroom with a nude woman reclining on a beach. Weigl interior gates in the living rom are worthy of a 1920s black and white movie. Entry was from the lake, the only way to reach the house as 'River Avenue' as Scenic Dr. was than called, was a dirt path. The metal spider web, with spider, sprawling across the exterior of the front entry window is the reward for climbing the zillion steps from the dock to the 'front door'. Stones used in the building were leftovers from the dam collapse, or from the quarry near what is now Cherry and Rockmoor. The architecture of the house uses many styles . Something that I think gives it a delightfully quirky quality. I don't know of another house in Austin with the same structural enchantment. On to the surrounding area which contributes to the cultural/historical associations. 2002 Scenic has the house, side building, glasshouse, (where Debbie's mother grew prize roses), pool with dressing cabanas, terraced gardens, stone bridge leading to the gardners' cottage‐ 2000 Scenic. An entire estate, relatively untouched for 100 years. Other rock houses were occupied by UT art professors, (1st UT art classroom was at 2105 Scenic), executive editor of newspaper lived at 2005 Scenic, ( built by Raymond Delisle), Commodore Edgar Perry built home at 3810 Kennelwood for Edgar, Jr. and Julie Matthews Perry. Kennelwood Clubhouse, for those of you who may remember Kennelwood Boat Docks, was at the southern end of Scenic where it intersects with Kennelwood. 'Tot' Hart, built the house at 2008 Scenic. His grandson, Robert Redford, spent 13 summers as a boy visiting his grandfather, Mr. Redford kindly sent me a personal letter describing his time in Austin. Later on this home was divided up and rented out to a continual stream of 'frat boys'. I know because several grown men, when guests at a party being held at 2002 Scenic, told me that they 'Really used to have some good parties there." Frank Erwin was a renter there. The small house within the walls of 2008 Scenic is an original 'fish hut', ‐ one of the many which populated the 'fish camp', then way, way outside of Austin where the fishin' was good and the people scarce. Owner is currently Sandra Smith. 2002 Scenic Dr. is worth saving for another 100 years. 1 Thank you very much, Alison Hanks 2 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Adam T. Blanton < Wednesday, May 4, 2022 12:36 PM HPD Preservation Case number: GF22-047398-2002 Scenic Dr > Follow Up Flag: Flag Status: Follow up Flagged *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Amber, I'd like to express some concern over the demo of 2002 Scenic drive. It's hard to imagine a complete demo of all structures on the property as there are so many unique features in the structure, the history and the style of this space. I don't want to impede the new owner's plans but would like to encourage them to please consider keeping some or part of the history and of the structure that stands today with their plans for the lot. Thank you for your time. -Adam Blanton 3801 Stevenson Ave CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 1 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Laney Bevill Wednesday, May 4, 2022 2:53 PM HPD Preservation Case number: GF22-047398-2002 Scenic Dr *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Case number: GF22‐047398‐2002 Scenic Dr I oppose ! thank you ! ‐‐ "Fear does not prevent death. It prevents life" Naguib Mahfouz CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 1 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Harper Ray Wednesday, May 4, 2022 2:56 PM HPD Preservation Case number: GF22-047398-2002 Scenic Dr *** External Email ‐ Exercise Caution *** I oppose demolition. So much a part of neighborhood. At least save structure to north. Harper Ray 2107 Scenic dr Sent from my iPhone CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 1 May 26, 2022 Terri Myers, Chair City of Austin Historic Landmark Commission Re: 2002 Scenic Drive Dear Ms. Myers, Preservation Austin exists to empower Austinites to shape a more inclusive, resilient, and meaningful community culture through preservation. We love a good building, and write today to express our concern over the possible demolition of 2002 Scenic Drive (PR-2002-032448), a property that we believe is eligible for historic designation. Following the May HLC meeting during which this case was postponed, Preservation Austin conducted additional research into the history of the site beyond what was included in the case backup materials. Based on the backup materials and our additional research, Preservation Austin believes that the property meets the criteria for significance under Architecture and Historical Association. However, we also believe that additional research is needed and ask that HPO staff be given more time to research the complete history of this property so that the best preservation outcome may be achieved. The property on Scenic Drive retains integrity as defined by the National Register of Historic Places and clearly conveys historical significance. Its wholly unique design and landscape tell a distinct Austin story that we are just beginning to understand, and we echo neighbors’ extreme dismay that this rare architectural treasure might be razed. Preservation Austin believes the properties meet the following criteria for preservation under Austin’s current development code: Architecture: The primary building at 2002 Scenic Drive is a two-story Spanish eclectic residence with Modern and eclectic additions constructed during the historic period. Fenestration includes multi-light wood casement windows irregularly placed throughout. A cylindrical turret with a crenelated parapet and arched windows flanks an open masonry porch that leads to an expansive designed landscape. Both the exterior and interior feature elaborately carved keystones with human and animal motifs. The landscape features tinted concrete elements including a footbridge and a bench. Based on our research, we determined that 2002 Scenic Drive (formerly 2002 River Road) was built in 1923. Its architect is yet unclear; however, we know that the home was built by Raymond Delisle, who was the builder of several homes along Lake Austin around this time. Delisle was a businessman involved in many endeavors, including the Urnite Manufacturing Company, where he held the position of director. 2002 Scenic Drive’s architecture is extremely similar to that of the smaller cottage at 2005 Scenic Drive, which features stonework and a mantle bearing the face of a Viking, warranting additional research into this fanciful complex along Lake Austin. The property also resembles other stone homes at 2008, 2102, and 2105 Scenic Drive, clearly reflecting a development pattern in this area. Urnite Company was established as early as 1927. An ad for the company in 1929 stated that they manufactured “permanent rustic features made to order,” including fountains, birdbaths, benches, and other fixed and moveable objects similar to those seen in the landscape at 2002 Scenic Drive. A 1929 newspaper article in the Austin American describes the Urnite Company employing a “special Spanish process” to create a faux-wood effect out of tinted concrete that its staff learned from Mexican artisans. This technique is almost certainly that of faux bois or trabajo rústico. Faux bois (French for “false wood”) is a technique in which concrete structures resemble rustic wood or pieces of fallen or decaying trees. The material thus gives the impression of being malleable and organic in form. In Austin, the most prominent example of faux bois is the Briones House on E. 7th Street, colloquially known as Casa de Sueños. It was designed and built by Mexican artisan and builder Genaro P. Briones and completed in 1947. Briones worked with Mexican-born builder Dionicio Rodriguez, known for his masterful designs and artistic techniques. He was best known for his expertise in concrete faux bois, a style he learned while in Mexico. Rodriguez most frequently used the faux bois technique in footbridges, benches, and shelters. The influence of his work is quite evident in Briones’ home, particularly the outdoor furniture Genaro constructed for his own terrace and grotto. This method of applying tinted and sculpted stucco to reinforced concrete was not common in Texas, which makes Rodriguez’s and Briones’ constructions all the more unique. In addition to describing the Urnite Company’s work in manufacturing objects made of tinted concrete, and referencing Rodriguez’ work in San Antonio’s Brackenridge Park, the 1929 Austin American article mentioned that the Urnite Company was conducting work on the Delisle House that would create a “woodland scene” once completed. While further investigation is needed to determine the exact relationship between this work and the current conditions at 2002 Scenic Drive, the documentation suggests that the property is likely home to the earliest known example of the faux bois technique in Austin, predating the Briones House by nearly twenty years. Historical Association: Based on our initial research, Raymond Delisle appears to have been a prominent businessman involved in many ventures. As previously mentioned, he built several houses around Lake Austin and owned an optical business that was operational as early as 1921. He and his wife, Ammon, were socially active and their home on Lake Austin is referenced in newspapers as the “Delisle place” by the late 1920s. He continued to pursue real estate endeavors around Austin into the 1940s and was a member of the Chamber of Commerce and the Lions Club. He passed away in 1953. Additional research is needed into Raymond Delisle and the Urnite Company to determine if its association is significant. As the backup report identifies, the property also appears to have significant historical associations with longtime residents CH and Mildred Slator, who purchased the property in 1946. Slator was a prominent local attorney and co-owner of the Tavern circa 1953 and came from a prominent Llano family. The home stayed in the Slator family until 2021. The property is also significant for its association with Fehr & Granger. Established in 1946, Fehr & Granger was one of the first and possibly most influential mid-century modern architectural firms in Austin. They designed a c. 1946-47 addition to the house. The residence at 2002 Scenic Drive clearly displays a high degree of historic significance worthy of historic designation; however, the story of its association with Raymond Delisle, the Urnite Company, and its application of the faux bois technique merits further investigation. We urge the Historic Landmark Commission to allow staff additional time to conduct this research with the ultimate recommendation of individual landmark designation for the property. Thank you for your service to our community Linda Y. Jackson, President 2002 Scenic Drive The original house (not the 1940s renovation portion) is a stone structure with many wonderful stone carvings. The construction and stone carvings are similar (but much more elaborate) than the other remaining stone “fishing cabins” built at the same period. The photos below show some of this beautiful work on the exterior of the home. 2002 Scenic Drive case # PR-2022-032448 2002 Scenic Drive Photos of some of the stone work in the interior of the home. Carvings are placed randomly throughout the stone portions of the home. 2002 Scenic Drive case # PR-2022-032448 2002 Scenic Drive Photos of some of the stone work in the auxiliary building. 2002 Scenic Drive case # PR-2022-032448 Phil Gilbert 3805 Stevenson Ave. Austin, Texas 78703 May 3, 2022 City of Austin Residential Permitting To Whom It May Concern, Re: Objection to Complete Demolition of 2002 Scenic Drive, Austin, Texas I am opposed to the complete demolition of the house at 2002 Scenic Drive, Austin. I live across the street and while a complete demo and new build would no doubt be quicker, it is worth the time and effort to see that the essence of the beautiful, important structure(s) be built upon, not completely torn down. Austin offers a lot to the imagination. It’s that mythology, if you will, that is fueling our growth; it’s enticing hundreds of thousands to become new Austinites. That’s good. Bob Dylan wrote: “He not busy being born is busy dying.” Austin is constantly being born — from the 70’s “outlaws” that turned us into “the live music capital of the world” through to the 21st century technologists we are home to today. Change is good. But we must direct that change into something that is authentic. Something of Austin, not just in Austin. Change for change sake is childish… and change for convenience sake is even worse: it threatens the essence of the Austin ethic that is the wellspring for each renewal. The house at 2002 Scenic Drive is a great example of that weird, wonderful Austin ethic. It may be one of only a handful of remaining properties with this aesthetic. In fact, Scenic Drive itself is an Austin icon… and on Scenic there's only one other house that achieves the result of the house at 2002 Scenic — and it’s The Rock House, right next door. (It also has a colorful history… no doubt when Robert Redford was coming to play at his grandparents’ Rock House in those 1950’s summers he played with friends next door!) 1 of 2 I won’t speak much about the specific architectural and design elements that can never be recreated except to say: why would we destroy these last of a kind works when there is no need? The exterior easily displays its uniqueness. But inside is where the magic truly happens. There are literally dozens of one-of-a-kind design elements that would be destroyed forever, if we allowed a total demolition. If you question their value, then go to the property to see them yourself! While we want growth, we surely don’t want indiscriminate and undifferentiated mansions that inspire nothing more than calculations of price per square foot and “oh my gosh what a view.” If you buy a property with this beauty, history and landmark location I would hope you pay homage to it, restoring and renovating it into a modern expression of itself. I hope the house at 2002 Scenic is restored and renovated into a new architectural masterpiece that will inspire citizens 100 years from today to fight for it, as we fight for this 100 year old masterpiece. I strongly urge the City to reject the complete demolition of 2002 Scenic Drive. I also urge the City to approve any limited demolition only with simultaneous approval of the new home to be built, so that the essence of the property can be assured, prior to the demo of the old one. Sincerely yours, /s/ Phil Gilbert cc: Mayor Pro-Tem Alison Alter 2 of 2 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Collins, Kimberly Thursday, August 4, 2022 2:01 PM Allen, Amber FW: C14H-2002-0099 Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet ‐‐‐‐‐Original Message‐‐‐‐‐ From: TWT Sent: Thursday, August 4, 2022 12:43 PM To: Collins, Kimberly <Kimberly.Collins@austintexas.gov> Subject: C14H‐2002‐0099 *** External Email ‐ Exercise Caution *** Dear Kimberly, My husband and I mailed the forms stating our support of rezoning 2002 Scenic. However, in case the mail doesn’t arrive by the deadline, we would like to state it here also. Thank you, Tracy and Jay Thomas CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 1 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Collins, Kimberly Thursday, August 4, 2022 2:03 PM Allen, Amber FW: Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099) Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://bit.ly/HPDLobbyingForm Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet From: Collins, Kimberly Sent: Thursday, August 4, 2022 11:13 AM To: Rivera, Andrew <Andrew.Rivera@austintexas.gov> Subject: FW: Scenic Drive (Case # C14H‐2022‐0099) On Thu, Aug 4, 2022 at 8:54 AM gari wier wrote: Use your power to leave 2022 scenic drive at its original place… it’s what makes my city of 68 years a desirable place. It is admired greatly and once it’s gone history will be demolished. Sincerely GARi WIER Sent from my iPhone 1 licious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 2 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Collins, Kimberly Thursday, August 4, 2022 2:04 PM Allen, Amber FW: 2002 Scenic Drive Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://bit.ly/HPDLobbyingForm Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet From: Collins, Kimberly Sent: Wednesday, August 3, 2022 4:17 PM To: Rivera, Andrew <Andrew.Rivera@austintexas.gov> Subject: FW: 2002 Scenic Drive Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://bit.ly/HPDLobbyingForm 1 Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet From: Steve Luning Sent: Tuesday, August 2, 2022 6:27 PM To: Collins, Kimberly <Kimberly.Collins@austintexas.gov> Subject: 2002 Scenic Drive Dear Ms. Collins, (cid:1) *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** I am writing to you regarding 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099). I urge you to support the unanimous recommendation of the Historic Landmark Commission to change the zoning to SF-3-NP-H. (cid:1) I live across the street from 2002 Scenic Drive and have owned my house since 2006 and, through the years, I have appreciated the uniqueness of the house inside and out. The view from my house, and from the street, provides glimpses of the lake and a view of Tarrytowns history. It is significant that 2002 Scenic Drive was and is the anchor point for the immediate neighborhood. If this property is not protected, it’s likely to be replaced by multiple large houses to maximize the value of the owner’s investment. Please support the Historic Landmark Commission’s unanimous recommendation and help preserve the character of my neighborhood. Steve Luning CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 2 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Collins, Kimberly Thursday, August 4, 2022 2:04 PM Allen, Amber FW: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099) Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://bit.ly/HPDLobbyingForm Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet From: Collins, Kimberly Sent: Wednesday, August 3, 2022 3:42 PM To: Rivera, Andrew <Andrew.Rivera@austintexas.gov> Subject: FW: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H‐2022‐0099) Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://bit.ly/HPDLobbyingForm 1 Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet From: Laura Des Enfants < Sent: Wednesday, August 3, 2022 10:57 AM To: Collins, Kimberly <Kimberly.Collins@austintexas.gov> Subject: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H‐2022‐0099) *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Dear Kimberly, As the city of Austin grows we are undergoing many changes—mostly good ones. That said it is important during this growth spurt to preserve our architectural history in all neighborhoods to ensure we don’t end up with a neighborhood like Penn Station in NYC. I am writing specifically about 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H‐2022‐0099). I really want you to support the unanimous recommendation of the Historic Landmark Commission to change the zoning to SF‐3‐NP‐H. I have lived within two blocks of the 2002 Scenic Drive since 2013. If this property is not protected, it’s likely to be replaced by multiple large houses to maximize the value of the owner’s investment. While that may be good for the property owner it’s not good for this neighborhood nor for the preservation and architectural history of Austin. Please support the Historic Landmark Commission’s unanimous recommendation and help preserve the character of my neighborhood. Best, Laura Des Enfants CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 2 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Collins, Kimberly Thursday, August 4, 2022 2:04 PM Allen, Amber FW: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099)-public comment Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://bit.ly/HPDLobbyingForm Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet From: Collins, Kimberly Sent: Wednesday, August 3, 2022 3:34 PM To: Rivera, Andrew <Andrew.Rivera@austintexas.gov> Subject: FW: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H‐2022‐0099)‐public comment FYI Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://bit.ly/HPDLobbyingForm 1 Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet From: Lisa Gilbert < Sent: Wednesday, August 3, 2022 3:01 PM To: Collins, Kimberly <Kimberly.Collins@austintexas.gov> Subject: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H‐2022‐0099) *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Dear Kimberly, I am writing you regarding 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099). I support the Historic Planning Commissions unanimous recommendation to make this home a historic landmark. I am a neighbor, and my home was originally a fishing cabin built about the same time as this house. The corner of Scenic Drive and Stevenson Avenue has six of these old fishing cabins/stone houses remaining. Most have been modified like this home, but all have keep a portion of the stone cabins intact. If the previous family, who owned this property for 50 plus years had applied for Historic Landmark Status they surely would have received it with no questions asked. I understand why the new owners purchased the property, it has a beautiful view. But, the unique stone carvings both inside and out are truly special along with two interesting buildings could make this property one of the first "keep Austin Weird" houses. This house helps to keep our neighborhood feel like old Austin. And another large modern house will only scream we have money, while the entire community will lose a bit of Austin’s history and character. I ask that you support the Historic Planning Commissions recommendation and help preserve the character of my neighborhood. Thank you. Lisa Gilbert CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 2 Allen, Amber From: Sent: To: Subject: Collins, Kimberly Thursday, August 4, 2022 2:05 PM Allen, Amber FW: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099) Kimberly B. Collins Senior Planner‐Historic Preservation Office Department of Housing and Planning 512.974.1801 | kimberly.collins@austintexas.gov Pronouns: she/her/hers Historic Preservation | AustinTexas.gov PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://bit.ly/HPDLobbyingForm Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs Please Note: Correspondence and information submitted to the City of Austin are subject to the Texas Public Information Act (Chapter 552) and may be published online. Tenga en cuenta: La correspondencia y la información enviada a la Ciudad de Austin están sujetas a la Ley de Información Pública de Texas (Capítulo 552) y pueden publicarse en línea por la internet From: Collins, Kimberly Sent: Tuesday, August 2, 2022 10:05 AM To: Rivera, Andrew <Andrew.Rivera@austintexas.gov> Subject: FW: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H‐2022‐0099) From: John Falvey Sent: Monday, August 1, 2022 2:18 PM To: Collins, Kimberly <Kimberly.Collins@austintexas.gov> Subject: 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H‐2022‐0099) *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Dear Ms. Collins, the letter below was emailed to Planning Commissioners yesterday. Sincerely, John Falvey 1 I am writing to you regarding 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099). I urge you to support the unanimous recommendation of the Historic Landmark Commission to change the zoning to SF-3-NP-H. I have lived within two blocks of the 2002 Scenic Drive since 1991. Throughout this period I have appreciated looking at the buildings and grounds of this unique property. The view from the street with glimpses of the lake conjures the old, tranquil Austin and anchors the immediate neighborhood. If this property is not protected, it’s likely to be replaced by multiple large houses to maximize the value of the owner’s investment. Please support the Historic Landmark Commission’s unanimous recommendation and help preserve the character of my neighborhood. Thank You, John Falvey Sent from my iPad CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. 2 Dear Ms. Collins, I am writing to you regarding 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099). I urge you to support the unanimous recommendation of the Historic Landmark Commission to change the zoning to SF-3-NP-H. I have lived within two blocks of the 2002 Scenic Drive since 2001. Throughout this time, our family has marveled at this unique property and always wondered who owned and built it. The view from the street, with Lake Austin in the background, is reminiscent the old, tranquil Austin and is one of the few remnants of some of the unique remaining architecture in the neighborhood. It would be unfortunate if this property is not protected. The likelihood it will to be replaced by a single McMansion or multiple large houses to maximize the value of the owner’s investment would be tragic and disruptive to the neighborhood for years to come. Please support the Historic Landmark Commission’s unanimous recommendation and help preserve the character of my neighborhood. Thank you for your consideration in saving this amazing property. Mark and Stefanie Hernandez August 4, 2022 To Whom It May Concern: I am writing to you regarding 2002 Scenic Drive (Case# C14H-2022-0099) I urge you to support the unanimous recommendation of the Historic Landmark Commission to change the zoning to SF-3- NP-H. I have lived in a neighborhood adjacent to this property for over 18 years. I walk often and have enjoyed the presence of this lovely property on numerous occasions. The view from the street with glimpses of the lake call to mind the spirit of the heart of old Austin and its tranquil scenes. If this property is not protected, it is, in all probability, doomed to be replaced by soulless multiple large houses to maximize the value of the owner’s investment. Please support the Historic Landmark Commission’s unanimous recommendation and help preserve the character of this unique place. Respectfully, From: To: Subject: Date: Alison Tartt BC-Claire.Hemple@austintexas.gov; Cohen, Jessica - BC; BC-Carman.Llanes@austintexas.gov; Howard, Patrick - BC; Praxis, Solveij - BC; BC-Jeffery.Thompson@austintexas.gov; Mushtaler, Jennifer - BC; Cox, Grayson - BC; Shaw, Todd - BC; Schneider, Robert - BC; Flores, Yvette - BC; Azhar, Awais - BC; Anderson, Greg - BC; BC- James.Sheih@austintexas.gov; District10; Collins, Kimberly 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099) Monday, August 8, 2022 6:29:50 AM *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Dear Members of the Planning Commission, This letter concerns 2002 Scenic Drive (Case # C14H-2022-0099). I'm writing to urge the Planning Commission to support the unanimous recommendation of the Historic Landmark Commission to change the property's zoning to SF-3-NP-H. Saving this property from the wrecking ball would give well-deserved recognition to the neighborhood contributions of Raymond M. Delisle, a figure little known to most Austinites today but a prominent and enterprising "hobbyist builder / developer" in his day. With no formal training in architecture or landscape design, Delisle built sixteen rock homes in this Laurel Heights neighborhood between the late 1920s and the onset of World War II. The first and most impressive of these was his home at 2002 Scenic. Most of his other houses have regrettably been razed or undergone modifications that have obscured their original character. Protecting the distinctive structures and landscaping at 2002 Scenic would demonstrate that historic preservation is not simply about "George Washington Slept Here"; it is about fulfilling a community's obligations of stewardship as well as exercising the wisdom and foresight to defend aesthetic values against monetary considerations for the benefit of future generations. The property is not simply a beautiful example of extraordinarily imaginative craftsmanship in a spectacular setting; it is a truly unique remnant of Austin's prewar lake culture. This letter is not prompted by nostalgia for Old Austin's disappearing bungalows or animosity toward McMansions. It is written based on my experience of exploring the property several times in the spring (before trespassing was discouraged). I encountered many other visitors who were also roaming the buildings and grounds, and we all felt deep sadness over the possibility that this irreplaceable creation could be destroyed. Please support the Historic Landmark Commission’s unanimous recommendation. Sincerely, Alison Tartt Alison Tartt CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. From: To: Subject: Date: Contreras, Kalan Collins, Kimberly; Rivera, Andrew FW: Rezoning of 2002 Scenic Drive Monday, August 8, 2022 7:37:31 AM Kalan Contreras MSHP | Senior Planner | Historic Preservation Office Planning and Zoning Department 512.974.2727 | kalan.contreras@austintexas.gov -----Original Message----- From: Stephen Mytyk < Sent: Sunday, August 7, 2022 2:32 PM To: Contreras, Kalan <Kalan.Contreras@austintexas.gov> Subject: Rezoning of 2002 Scenic Drive *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Hello, Sincerely, Stephen Mytyk PER CITY ORDINANCE: All individuals scheduling or accepting a meeting invitation with a City Official are requested to provide responses to the questions at the following link: https://gcc02.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/? url=https%3A%2F%2Fbit.ly%2FHPDLobbyingForm&data=05%7C01%7CKimberly.Collins%40austintexas.gov%7C7d570ce5b5bd4de16c8908da793ac1c6%7C5c5e19f6a6ab4b45b1d0be4608a9a67f%7C0%7C0%7C637955590505922996%7CUnknown%7CTWFpbGZsb3d8eyJWIjoiMC4wLjAwMDAiLCJQIjoiV2luMzIiLCJBTiI6Ik1haWwiLCJXVCI6Mn0%3D%7C3000%7C%7C%7C&sdata=KfLB6JNXCqPFlPHEd7sPQmYuLCb7QZ9ezd65ZNALtUc%3D&reserved=0 Please note that all information provided is subject to public disclosure. For more information please visit: City of Austin Ordinance 2016-0922-005 | City Clerk’s website | City Clerk’s FAQs I am writing in opposition to the rezoning of 2002 Scenic Drive through the addition of an historical landmark designation. Using the power of the state to impose the value structures of particular individuals in the neighborhood, who happen to prefer preservation of old buildings, is an unacceptable infringement of the property owner’s individual right to enjoy and dispose of their property as they see fit, so long as no actual physical violation is done to their neighbors in the process of doing so. Being unhappy about the prospects of a change in the perceived character of the neighborhood does not represent any such physical violation. As such I urge you to respect the rights of property owners in Austin to be free of coercion at the whims of their fellow citizens, and of the city government. was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov. From: To: Subject: Date: Kate Kyle Collins, Kimberly Zoning Case# C14H-2022-0099 Monday, August 8, 2022 7:46:15 AM *** External Email - Exercise Caution *** Hi - I am writing to support this case to rezone 2002 Scenic Drive to a Historic Landmark. I live on Matthews and took care to remodel my house to keep within the style, design and uniqueness of the neighborhood. It is what makes Austin, Austin to have these properties that reflect the character and history of the neighborhood over time. Thanks for your support and hard work. Regards, Kate Kyle CAUTION: This email was received at the City of Austin, from an EXTERNAL source. Please use caution when clicking links or opening attachments. If you believe this to be a malicious and/or phishing email, please forward this email to cybersecurity@austintexas.gov.