Item 17 - .JesusPantel-AppealsWorkingGroup_11-18-24.pdf — original pdf

Backup

Cultural Arts Funding Update Economic Development Department November 18, 2024 C I T Y O F A U S T I N Appeals Process • Approved at the June 29, 2022 Arts Commission meeting. • Eligible for Appeal: 1. Review Panelist or Staff Error 2. Conflict of interest • Link must be shown NOTE: "Even if an appeal is found to have merit, it may not change your score enough to reach funding. Successful appeals will only result in a funding award if the appeal raises your score to at least the minimum that received finding in the program." C I T Y O F A U S T I N Not Appealable • Subjective opinions • Assigned scores • Award amount • Issues of eligibility, guidelines, or policy NOTE: Dissatisfaction with the denial of an award or with the amount of the award is an insufficient reason for appeal. C I T Y O F A U S T I N Appeals Requests Appeal Form due by October 4, 2024 Arts Commission Appeals Working Group formed October 21, 2024 Recommendations voted on by Arts Commission Staff Review (October 7- 18, 2024) Appeals Working Group Meet & Makes Recommendations (November 14, 2024) • • 22 appeals submitted 4 Appeals eligible to move forward C I T Y O F A U S T I N Appeals Recommendations 4 eligible 3 appeals upheld 2 appeals resulted in high enough scores to receive funding • Candyce Rusk dba FATHOM ~ Of Women and Water • Groundwork Music Project C I T Y O F A U S T I N Scoring and Funding Considerations Higher score from Funding Considerations • Changing specific appealed • At a level commensurate with rubric item other similar grants • Dropping that Panelist’s scores • At a special level based on City priorities • At a reduced level based upon the current status of the activity • At an adjusted level based on funds available C I T Y O F A U S T I N Candyce Rusk dba FATHOM Groundwork Music Project Appeal Award Amounts • Score changed from 75.5 to 83.67 • Minimum Elevate for Individuals/Creative Businesses score to receive funding was 81 • Similar scoring Elevate for Individuals/Creative Businesses applicants (81 to 87.3) received a $15,000 award C I T Y O F A U S T I N • This was the appeal that the Working Group specifically asked that the Panelist score be thrown out • Score changed from 71 to 84 • Minimum Elevate for Nonprofits score to receive funding was 72.2 • Similar scoring Elevate for Nonprofits applicants (81.75 to 87) received a $60,000 award Questions?